May. 17th, 2004 08:53 am
So you wanna be part of the gang?
Since someone actually made the "no worse than a fraternity hazing" argument in a response in this journal, this entry I posted elsewhere is relevant here as well. (Original context in
tbearpsy's journal. [WARNING! Entry contains pics from Abu Ghraib.])
![[livejournal.com profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/external/lj-userinfo.gif)
I think the "no worse than a fraternity hazing" arguments are really off base. They only consider the physical acts completely divorced from their psychological context. First of all, hazings are voluntary; if you don't want to go through one, don't join a society that organises them. Second, why does someone choose to undergo a hazing? To become a full member of a group. They satisfy a deep craving to belong to something.
The abuse of prisoners in Abu Ghraib was intended to have precisely the opposite effect. Undergoing it didn't make the Iraqis PiKEs or lacrosse team members; it only made them more outcast. Even if no one they care about saw the pictures, they know deep down they were forced to perform humiliating acts while being powerless to stop them. Can you imagine how damaging that must be? It's less like a hazing than a gay-bashing.
There is a line at murder, though; unfortunately, it's been hinted that the newest revelations include accusations of rape and murder. A lot more people will need to be brought to justice before we can close this ignonimous chapter of the occupation.