Oct. 15th, 2003 10:24 am
I know it when I see it
So, members of the Dewey Committee is even as we speak meeting with the leading lights of a niche publishing industry in order to resolve one of the great questions of our time:
I gave her my two cents, which is that this a Pornography vs. Erotica debate. (That raised her eyebrows a tad!) That is, if I think it's good, it's a graphic novel, otherwise it's just a comic book. I did tentatively suggest some other (arbitrary, inconsistently-applied) criteria, but before I mention these, I'd like to hear a few reactions. After all, this is an issue that's near and dear to many of youovergrown kimature consumers of quality illustrated literature, isn't it?
Fortunately, for some weighty questions, there are definitive answers. If you don't believe me, type "answer to life the universe and everything" into Google.
Comic book or Graphic novel?I found this out from my boss, who serves on the Committee. She had with her copies of Akira and The League of Extraordinary Gentleman and was vainly struggling to determine which category each belonged to.
I gave her my two cents, which is that this a Pornography vs. Erotica debate. (That raised her eyebrows a tad!) That is, if I think it's good, it's a graphic novel, otherwise it's just a comic book. I did tentatively suggest some other (arbitrary, inconsistently-applied) criteria, but before I mention these, I'd like to hear a few reactions. After all, this is an issue that's near and dear to many of you
Fortunately, for some weighty questions, there are definitive answers. If you don't believe me, type "answer to life the universe and everything" into Google.